As COP31 moves towards the announcement of its final decisions, divergent positions on the future of the Just Transition Work Programme, the operationalisation of the proposed mechanism and the means of implementation reveal a deeper challenge: fundamental questions of who pays, when, to whom and how still remain contested.
Alongside the intensive negotiations in Antalya, our researchers met for a ‘JUST a COP of tea’ session to share, discuss and reflect on what was happening 2,106 miles away. From Northern England, the geographical focus of our research, we followed these developments in COP31 and considered their implications for a just transition in our region.
Jingyi Li: Normalising overshoot at the expense of equity and justice
COP31 is the first climate summit since the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) concluded that exceeding 1.5°C is now expected, and the Antalya presidencies have made the response to overshoot a headline element of the proposed cover decision. This sends a very dangerous signal. Once overshoot is accepted as a planning assumption to guide the negotiations, equity and justice become more contested elements in this era that is already shaped by compounding crises.
Working through interpreting the meaning of overshoot, especially its connections to the just transition questions at the centre of my research, was a deeply uncomfortable experience. Two reports launched in the first week of COP31 facilitated me with deeper thinking. The Global Carbon Budget 2026 set out the physical reality that the 1.5°C budget is “virtually exhausted” - 150 billion tonnes of CO₂ remain for a 50% chance of limiting global warming to 1.5°C, which would be exhausted within two years at the 2025 emission rate. Meanwhile, the Civil Society Equity Review showed how sharply fair-share burdens differ between the Global North and South.
Against this backdrop, UNEP now presents “overshoot, peak and decline” as the best remaining pathway towards a return below 1.5°C. However, the IPCC warns that even temporary overshoot can cause irreversible ecological damage and heightened socio-economic risks, disproportionately affecting vulnerable communities. Overshoot deepens the distributive questions and concerns, intersecting with issues around development opportunities. Who used the budget before we are reaching 1.5°C? What the numbers themselves did not tell us in a complete picture is how the budget was consumed before we reached this point.
The UNFCCC itself recognises that the largest share of historical emissions originated in developed countries, many of which built their development trajectories on fossil fuel extraction and colonial resource flows. If overshoot creates “extra room” for emissions, whose development does that room serve? Who will pay for the large-scale carbon removal needed afterwards, and on whose land? The so-called “extra room” for emissions comes at the expense of equitable development, as the heightened climate risks and adaptation burdens associated with overshoot disproportionately affect vulnerable communities, further narrowing development opportunities for those already marginalised by historical and persistent inequalities.
As I argued in my previous analysis of the Jackdaw decision, the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities (CBDR-RC) should not stop at the international level. My research asks whether fuel-poor households in former coal mining communities (Wigan in Greater Manchester, and Gateshead in North East) can stay thermally comfortable as heating and cooling move to low-carbon systems, and the same three questions return. Who used the budget? Coal from these communities powered Britain’s industrialisation, and the UK’s place among the largest historical emitters is strongly tied to that coal, yet the wealth it generated accrued elsewhere. Taken together, the former coalfields would likely form the most deprived region in the UK.
Who gets the extra room? The 2026 Equity Review by Civil Society finds that the wealthiest people produce far more emissions and need to make much greater reductions than national averages suggest, and the same logic applies in the UK, while fuel-poor households often ration energy below what they need. Who pays? While the costs of overshoot and those of transitioning to low-carbon living are not identical, they raise similar questions about who has benefited from past emissions and who is expected to bear the costs of climate action. For households already struggling to afford adequate heating and cooling, the additional challenge of adapting to increasingly hot summers makes these questions particularly relevant.
Subina Shrestha: Reparative justice and the missing accountability in climate action
I am viewing equity as a central element while following this COP, particularly in relation to reparative justice - addressing historical injustices by holding those responsible to account and redressing the harm caused. In particular, the Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capacities (CBDR-RC) prevalent in UNFCCC negotiations recognises that historically, developed countries have had a higher cumulative contribution to CO2 emissions and therefore have a greater responsibility for climate action.
Given that those who have contributed the least to emissions are often the most vulnerable to its impacts, such a historical perspective has also allowed for centring reparative justice into COP31, primarily through discussions about responsibility for climate adaptation and resilience, as well as loss and damage for climate-induced disaster recovery and rehabilitation.
As climate extremes become the norm within the UK and globally, what might reparative justice look like, especially as infrastructural lock-ins are beginning to create open questions on risk and resilience? The Climate Change Committee estimated an annual investment of around £11 billion per year is needed from the public and private sectors for climate resilience. Where will this be deployed across the UK, and how? These are important questions in the context of redressing legacies of disinvestment and erosion of community infrastructure - essential pillars for resilience - particularly in the North of England.
The CCC similarly states that sea levels will be 20–45 cm higher around UK coasts than today, raising the severity and frequency of coastal flooding and coastal erosion. These phenomena render coastal communities particularly vulnerable, risking not just loss of physical infrastructure, but bringing fore questions of climate displacement. Broader discussions of loss and damage are highly relevant to the UK, too, as the country grapples with an aging infrastructure and planning that was not meant for a rapidly warming climate.
Which communities will face the greatest losses and what does it mean for our collective sense of belonging? Beyond physical infrastructure, protecting and strengthening social infrastructure, such as community spaces and support networks, is equally important for maintaining social connections and a sense of belonging amid the climate crisis.
Anna Key and Liz Edwards: Putting people and places at the centre of just transitions
While COP31 is rightly concerned with international responses and global targets, we must not underestimate the importance of placing communities at the centre of climate action. As discussions at COP31 continue through the Just Transition Work Programme, there is growing recognition that, in addition to carbon reductions, climate action must also deliver social and economic benefits. While COP30 agreed principles of a just transition mechanism, COP31 must now turn those principles into practice by defining what it is for, whom it serves and how it will be delivered.
Just transition is about much more than reducing carbon emissions. It also concerns issues such as health and wellbeing, and social inclusion. Carbon emissions alone are a crude and reductive measure. Policymakers must not lose sight of these other “softer” factors, otherwise they risk reproducing inequalities and losing trust and public support.
Bottom-up, grassroots approaches and quiet sustainability initiatives position communities and individuals as active agents for change rather than merely passive recipients of national policies. Community-led climate action recognises that local residents, communities, businesses and civic organisations often have the deepest understanding of environmental challenges in their places, and as such, grassroots climate action is likely to be better suited to local needs than (inter)nationally imposed policies and targets.
One example of this from our research is Todmorden Learning Centre and Community Hub and their Warmth Works retrofit project. The initiative is a direct response to a citizen’s jury recommendation, with local residents identifying the need for trusted, community-led support in addressing efficiency, comfort and health concerns relating to local pre-1919 housing stock. The project aims to provide the information, skills and materials needed to meet this challenge while creating opportunities for local people.
Participatory decision-making ensures that diverse voices are heard, which increases legitimacy and, in turn, trust. Place-based policies help identify practical local solutions more effectively, as they reflect local economic landscapes, social fabric, skills, infrastructure and cultural identities. In Merseyside, our collaboration with Kindred Liverpool City Region provides a practical example. Through the recent “Joined Up: Sustainable Connections” initiative, we have effectively implemented the co-creation approach, bringing together local communities, individuals and organisations to collectively identify priorities and shape locally relevant climate action.
This emphasis on community participation is also reflected in the open letter calling for the establishment of the Belém-Antalya Mechanism (BAM) for Just Transition, which calls for inclusive and democratic decision-making, ensuring that workers and communities have meaningful roles in decisions affecting their lives and livelihoods. As Norma Don Juan Pérez, an Indigenous Nahua woman from Mexico City and member of the National Coordinating Committee of Indigenous Women (CONAMI), stated: “We are not beneficiaries. We are environmental leaders sustaining life in our own territories.” While rooted in distinct Indigenous experiences and rights claims, this principle can be seen to resonate with climate action in Northern England, where local communities should be recognised not merely as passive recipients of transition policies, but as active partners in shaping decisions that affect their places, livelihoods and futures.
Collective reflection
The discussions during “JUST a COP of Tea” bring us back to the central questions guiding our research at the JUST Centre: what works, where, for whom, and whose voices shape the transition? Addressing emissions reductions, climate adaptation, affordability and wellbeing requires a joined-up, place-based approach that puts communities at its centre. Crucially, time must be recognised as a dimension of justice. The climate emergency demands not only effective implementation, but also an acceleration of action that does not compromise equity or community participation. Ultimately, the question is not simply who pays for overshoot, but who bears the costs of delay, and how quickly we can deliver just and equitable transitions.
Image credit: “COP31” by European Committee of the Regions, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.